Holden Arboretum Studies Resistant Beech and Ash Trees

Herein lies a post about the long, patient work that begins when something goes wrong with the world. With the introduction of beech leaf disease into North America, things have gone very wrong. Another noble, native tree species, towering and strong, is proving no match for a microscopic nematode. When this happens--yet another example of collateral damage from international trade--scientists mobilize to seek understanding and possible remedies.

In recent blog posts about beech leaf disease, I've mentioned Holden Arboretum. Holden happens to be located east of Cleveland, close to where the disease was first noticed back in 2012. Visiting family in Cleveland this summer during a band tour, I reached out to Holden staff to see if I could stop by to witness their research on the disease. 

Tucked behind some 3000 acres of gardens and ponds, forests and fields, is a research station where Holden is devoting staff and greenhouses to a collaboration with the U.S. Forest Service and others to test resistance not only beech leaf disease, but also to the introduced insects that have decimated two other native trees--ash and hemlock. 

I learned primarily about their research on beech and ash trees.

AMERICAN BEECH

Where did the nematode that causes beech leaf disease come from? According to Rachel Kappler, Holden's Forest Health Collaborative Coordinator, who generously came in on a Saturday to give me a tour, they have identified the island in Japan from which the nematode came. It was not a species from Asia's mainland. 

Holden's main endeavor is to seek out beech that show some resistance to the disease, and test that resistance. 

Rachel first grows seedlings that can be used as root stock for these tests. The root stock serves as the bottom half of a graft.

When trees are found that have lingered in the landscape while others succumb, Rachel then grafts cuttings from these "suspiciously healthy" trees onto the prepared rootstock. 

Once the grafts heal,

the trees can be tested for resistance. Measured numbers of nematodes are applied to the buds, documented with colored tags, and the tree's resistance to the nematodes is then observed.

The nematodes are small enough to enter the buds between the overlapping bud scales. The tiny worm-like creatures inhabit the leaves all summer. Then in fall, exiting the leaves through the stomata--the openings on the undersides of the leaves through which the tree breathes--the nematodes transfer to the new buds to overwinter.

Each step in the process of testing resistance takes time and consistent attention. Rachel says some promising means of speeding research are in the works. Promisingly resistant trees can be propagated using only their leaves. The leaves are cut, a particular root hormone applied, then the leaf is stuck in soil medium to grow. This approach could potentially avoid the need to grow root stock, grafting, and the time it takes for grafts to heal.

As for treatments for the disease, she says soil applications of phosphite have mostly been experimented with on smaller trees because it's easier to study at these smaller scales. Similarly, using chemical sprays on the trees' foliage requires just the right timing, and a thorough coating, which makes larger trees very difficult and expensive to spray. They are experimenting with pruning to allow better air circulation and thereby reduce the moisture that the nematodes like.

ASH TREES

Research on resistant ash trees is a little farther along. Rachel showed me a grove of young green ash--protected by a deer fence--that are being tested for resistance to the Emerald Ash Borer (EAB), which spread through Ohio nine years before Beech Leaf Disease. This is the same introduced insect that has decimated Princeton's ash trees.

Rachel explained that the ash can defend themselves from the burrowing insects in three ways. One is a blockage that prevents entry. Another is to react by building a wall around an ash borer that has gotten in under the bark. Another is to somehow deprive the ash borer of nutrition, so that it becomes stunted. 

Sticky boards are used to monitor the presence of Emerald Ash Borers at the site.

When I told her that I had only seen one adult Emerald Ash Borer in my life, despite the hundreds of millions of ash trees killed, she pulled one off of the sticky board.

In this closeup, the Emerald Ash Borer is on the left; a native ash borer, far less destructive, is on the right. Though they are similar in appearance, it's the difference in behavior of the introduced species that has proven lethal.

She said that ash trees become vulnerable to EAB attack fairly early in life, certainly under ten feet high. While some of the ash trees being tested in the grove are dying due to EAB (perhaps these are the controls in the experiment), 

many are doing well, showing some degree of resistance. 

The green ash that have proven resistant to the EAB must not only be able to survive at low EAB levels, but also when the Emerald Ash Borer is present in high numbers. Rigorous testing helps avoid later marketing an ash variety that ultimately could prove vulnerable. 

This scar is evidence of an inner struggle by the ash to fend off the borer. The tree tries to build walls around the EAB larvae. 

Rachel described an autoimmune reaction, observed in black ash up north, in which the tree is too aggressive in blocking off passages, interfering with its own circulation. 

She talked about the physical aspects of doing research on trees and their pathogens. The wooly adelgid that plagues our hemlocks is hard to study, in part because it can be hard to apply the soft insect to test trees without squashing its soft frame, so they use its eggs. Nematodes are much easier to count and apply to branches.

Expanded greenhouses suggest Holden is expanding its efforts to nurture trees resistant to imported insects and disease. 

One bonus from my visit was that Rachel took an interest in our efforts in Princeton to bring back the native butternut (Juglans cinerea), and has put us in touch with someone studying the species.

If, as beech leaf disease takes its toll on beech trees in Princeton, we see some trees that "linger" and remain "suspiciously healthy," we'll want to notify Holden Arboretum, to aid their ongoing search for resistant trees. 

A thunderstorm prevented me from exploring the many gardens at Holden that day, including a treetop walk and tower. And then there's the Cleveland Botanical Garden closer into town, with which Holden recently merged. These are some good botanical destinations in Cleveland, with a mission that extends far beyond the city, and an engaging origin story.